Jay’s Restaurant is, in effect, a continuation of Ritty’s Pony House. The bar saw service from 1882 until 1967, even through the Prohibition years. In those dry years, Ritty’s Pony House Saloon became the Pony House Stag Hotel, and the Pony House Restaurant and Cafe. The light fixtures at Jay’s are antiques, although the origin is unknown. The railing comes from the Old Xenia Hotel and the back of its oyster bar is from College Corner, Ohio. The plaque in the vestibule is from the original gates of the Montgomery County Fair Grounds dated 1901.